Technical insights

How to Compare Freight Elevator Supplier Quotations

Digitally enhanced concept based on a FEIYA 3-tonne freight elevator photo, illustrating a guide to comparing supplier quotations.

To compare freight elevator quotations, first make the offers comparable: the same loading task, usable space, building assumptions and supply boundary. Then review the prices. If an offer leaves something out, the comparison needs either a separately supported cost or an open question. Entering zero would imply that the missing work is free.

FEIYA Elevator publishes this guide for the stage when several proposals are on the desk. Our freight elevator cost guide explains the price drivers. This article deals with the next job: turning offers written in different formats into a decision record, while keeping technical alternatives and unpriced work visible.

Give every offer a document reference

At the top of the comparison sheet, identify the common enquiry revision. Under each supplier's name, enter its quotation reference, date and the drawing it used. These small fields establish which documents the figures belong to. Keep the brief with the sheet: goods, proposed load, handling method, stops, travel, entrances and available shaft information.

A measurement taken from an old plan should be labelled differently from a confirmed site measurement. If a candidate has priced an assumption, carry that assumption into its column. When a revised quotation arrives, the previous one stays in the archive; only the identified current version supplies the active price.

A proposed alternative deserves its own entry. Suppose one supplier offers a smaller car than the brief requests. Keep the original requirement in the comparison and place the smaller car below it, with the supplier's explanation. The technical team can then decide whether the alternative is acceptable without losing track of what the other candidates were asked to price.

Tonnage is one field in a larger specification

The same rated load does not establish that two elevators will perform the same task. Compare usable car dimensions, clear entrance dimensions, door arrangement, rated speed, stops and travel separately. Keep the labels and units visible. A car's outside dimensions cannot be substituted for its usable internal dimensions in a purchasing comparison.

FEIYA's historical parameter sheet provides a useful illustration. It contains two entries at 5,000 kg and 0.5 m/s. Both list a clear door opening of 2,000 × 2,100 mm, but their recorded car and shaft dimensions differ:

Field in the historical sheetFirst 5,000 kg entrySecond 5,000 kg entry
Car inner dimensions, width × depth2,230 × 3,970 mm2,230 × 3,910 mm
Car outer dimensions, width × depth2,300 × 4,200 mm2,300 × 4,300 mm
Shaft inside dimensions, width × depth3,600 × 4,500 mm3,600 × 4,630 mm

These are historical reference entries from FEIYA's archive, not current standard configurations or construction requirements. The sheet does not explain the model or structural differences between these rows. They should be kept as separate entries, without combining a car dimension from one with a shaft dimension from the other. Final dimensions require a project-specific proposal based on the customer's needs, site conditions and approved drawings.

For quotation review, the lesson is straightforward: matching the tonnage and speed still leaves other fields to reconcile. Ask each supplier to explain the arrangement it has priced. Our freight elevator product page introduces the product range; the actual comparison should use the specifications offered for your building.

Give the loading assumption its own row

Write down the total load expected to enter the car, rather than just the weight of the goods. Pallets, trolleys and other handling equipment may form part of the task. Whether a person or forklift enters also needs to be addressed in the intended-use review. A capacity figure alone does not establish permission for either.

Consider a hypothetical pair of proposals. One assumes that a handling truck stays outside while goods are transferred at the landing; the other is being discussed for a truck entering the car. Those offers are not yet comparable, even if both show the same rated load. The supplier needs the relevant equipment and loading information before confirming suitability.

Avoid calculating a price adjustment yourself for such a difference. Record the requirement, ask for the technical response and obtain a revised offer if necessary. A cheaper configuration that does not suit the agreed loading method is an alternative to evaluate, not a direct substitute.

Write down the stops and the actual entrance arrangement

A short description such as “three-floor goods lift” can leave important questions unanswered. List the required served stops, the intended entrance arrangement at each level and the travel information used for the offer. Clarify any through-car or opposite-side access requirement in the drawings.

Do not assume that the number of floors describes every door opening or the vertical travel. The supplier should state what it has allowed for. If the two proposals use different building assumptions, have those assumptions corrected before treating the totals as a meaningful price difference.

Our two-stop versus three-stop quotation guide discusses this particular comparison in more detail. In your working sheet, retain the actual stops and travel as separate fields. That makes a later change easier to trace than a general note saying the lift has become larger.

Request a FEIYA freight elevator quotation by sharing drawings, the loading method and the required supply scope.

Use four scope statuses instead of a blank cell

Four labels make the scope review easier to use: included, excluded, provisional and awaiting clarification. For an included item, retain the description or quotation reference. For an excluded item, identify who will provide it. Provisional means that the allowance or assumption still needs confirmation. Awaiting clarification means you do not yet know what the offer provides.

The table below is a comparison structure, not a completed assessment of any company:

Comparison rowInformation to requestHow to treat an unresolved answer
Equipment supplyIdentified configuration and itemised supply descriptionKeep the configuration difference visible
Packing and deliveryPacking scope, destination and responsibility boundaryRequest a written delivery clarification
Unloading and storageParty responsible and any supplier attendanceRetain a separate local allowance if needed
Installation and commissioningWork included and who will perform itObtain the installer's scope and price
DocumentationDocument list, language, format and timingRecord the missing document requirement
Service and spare partsSupport scope and proposed parts provisionClarify the actual support arrangement

An equipment-only proposal can be compared with a broader proposal, but first account for the additional work the buyer will procure. If installation comes from another company, link that company's scope to the equipment offer it has reviewed. This makes the comparison about the same project outcome, rather than about how much each supplier has chosen to put inside its own contract.

Keep the supplier price and the comparison total separate

The supplier's total should remain exactly as quoted. Add a separate calculation for the buyer's comparison, where documented costs outside that offer can be included. Beside each adjustment, record its source, date and scope. That leaves a reviewer able to reconstruct the total without opening every email in the purchasing file.

For example, if installation is excluded, a local installer's proposal may provide a usable allowance after it has reviewed the relevant technical information. A purchasing team's unsupported guess should not be presented as a confirmed installation price. If there is no reliable figure yet, leave the item open and state what is needed to price it.

Keep options in a separate section until a common choice has been made. A finish upgrade included by one candidate and offered separately by another can otherwise distort the base comparison. Check for duplicate allowances too: a delivery charge broken out for explanation may already be part of the quoted total. Add it only if the document makes clear that it is additional.

Where quotations use different currencies, record the rate, date and source used for the comparison. Keep the original amounts as well. This is a way to make the worksheet reproducible, not a prediction of what exchange rate will apply when payment is due.

Compare the event that starts the delivery period

Read the event that starts the proposed delivery period. Is the offer based on an order, an agreed payment milestone, approved drawings or receipt of complete technical information? Ask the supplier to identify the conditions it has used. A shorter period is difficult to interpret if its starting event is different.

Separate production readiness from transport and local site readiness. The project may also depend on drawings, building preparation or installation arrangements that are outside the manufacturing schedule. Put those dependencies in the project discussion rather than treating a stated production period as the complete handover date.

Record offer validity and the circumstances requiring a revised quotation. If the specification changes during review, obtain an updated document that identifies the change. A price carried forward from an obsolete drawing should not remain the active comparison simply because it was the first figure approved internally.

Bring component changes and service scope into the review

Compare the components actually identified in each proposal. Where only a brand is given, ask which model or specification is intended where relevant to the technical review. More familiar branding does not, by itself, show how the supplied system will meet the project brief.

Agree how substitutions will be proposed and approved. The buyer needs enough information to review a replacement and understand any effect on the specification, maintenance or documentation. Keep agreed changes with the revised quotation instead of relying on a separate verbal assurance.

For after-sales support, compare what the receiving team can use: the contact route, language, availability, information needed for a service request and the proposed spare-parts arrangement. Warranty wording should identify scope, exclusions and the agreed start event. Labour, travel and freight should be clarified where relevant, rather than assumed to be covered by a general promise of support.

Return a short list of specific questions

At this point the worksheet should reveal the questions that affect the decision. Number them and send the relevant list to each supplier with the current brief attached. Use a concrete request: identify the internal car dimensions, confirm the drawing revision, or describe the installation allowance. A general request to improve the price will not close those gaps.

For instance, a clarification might ask the supplier to confirm the internal car dimensions, identify the drawing revision used and state whether installation is included. Attach the relevant brief rather than relying on earlier correspondence being found. Ask for changes to be reflected in the revised quotation or an identified attachment.

For the final review, separate three things: confirmed scope, estimates supported by a stated source, and questions still open. An alternative can be worth accepting, but record who reviewed it and why. If an important cost remains unknown, show the purchasing approver exactly which decision would be premature. The worksheet should make uncertainty visible rather than disguise it inside a precise-looking total.

To request a FEIYA quotation on a defined basis, send your project drawings, loading method and required supply scope. Include the points you need the offer to address. You do not need to share another supplier's confidential quotation to explain your requirements; a clear comparison brief is enough to begin the discussion.

PROJECT SUPPORT

Planning an Elevator Project?

Share your project requirements with FEIYA. We can review the available information and discuss suitable elevator configuration options based on your project conditions.

REQUEST A QUOTE CONTACT ON WHATSAPP

Discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

From the archive

View all news & insights ↗